She could see his face -- she even begged him to stop. Christy Jack: They met on the tennis courts. Cullen Davis would soon be in trouble again -- and this time, he was squarely in the crosshairs of Jack Strickland. They had already confessed and the physical evidence was overwhelming. Christy Jack: The chemistry cools. DREW Sr. Kenneth In the 1930s, Joe Ball's murder spree was such a media sensation that it nearly became the stuff of tall tales, but Ball's numerousfemale victims were quite real - as were the alligators he fed their bodies to. He doesn't look like the usual creep that -- that they brought in. Jack Strickland | Former DA: His worth was estimated at about $500 million. And he was -- not 100 percent savory character. I thought she was the reporter and he was the hyperactive nephew," Jones said. On the first floor of the house, the bullet-riddled body of Priscilla Davis' boyfriend, Stan Farr, lay crumpled in the kitchen; another man, Bubba Gavrel, was alive, but paralyzed. Haynes was also a mentor to Dan Cogdell, who studied Haynes' work on the Davis case. HAYNES, Ramiro Its Time For Restaurant Roundup, [PHOTOS] The Day that the Texas Panhandle Got an Unusual Dusting. Cullen Davis said he'd been in bed at Karen's at the time of the shootings. [3] On Saturday, December 6, 1997, a confrontation occurred at the IHOP involving Dustin Camp, a student and football player for Tascosa High School in Amarillo, and John King, a member of the punk rock community. Both Priscilla and Cullen were married with children when they first laid eyes on each other. [16][17], The widely syndicated City Confidential episode "Amarillo, TX: High School Hit & Run" in 2005 reinforced interest in the case. MARTINEZ, Ireneo And when it went bad, it went really bad. Will It Feel Like Spring In Amarillo? Although there were multiple crimes, Jack Strickland says his colleagues in the DA's office decided to try this one first. Christy Jack: I don't think of it as a case as being unsolved. He had there suitcases -- one for him, one for Harper Lee, and the other full of J&B Scotch. And on that August night, the couple were out again leaving Andrea alone doing schoolwork safe, her mother thought. Consequently, the murder of Earl Dockray shocked Amarillo and forced the town to become more involved with law and order. The defense theory turned the whole case upside down. Smith was more complicated, the son in a bad home life. Punks in Amarillo reported that they had often been targets of abuse and harassment by jocks because of their differences, even before the incident; after the trial there was a general feeling that Camp walked free because he was seen as a "good kid", unlike the punks. Watts was active for eight years throughout the '70s. A man walking his dog had just discovered the body of 19-year-old Crystal Booker. Smith became friends with Capote. After all, he had plenty of money. GENTRY, Michael Dean While Andrea was home in the mansion, Priscilla Davis and her boyfriend, Stan Farr, were out on the town. The Bowery District, filled with saloons, brothels, and gambling dens, had the reputation of consisting of transients, gamblers, prostitutes, and thugs who would slug you for a quarter- or kill you for a dollar.. David McCrory: I got Judge Eidson dead for you. Maureen Maher: Does a man of God have to confess his sins publicly? She said, "I didn't think it was important. There was one person and one person only that was prosecuted at that trial. Maureen Maher: Was he ever abusive to you? And Davis' attorneys weren't the only ones collecting money from him. Most of them, Weird Things Texans Could Throw Into A Drive-Thru Window. David McCrory: I'll get the rest of them dead for you. "Hickock was the airplane, and Smith the bomb. And a documentary, "Cold Blooded" aired last fall when for the first time Clutter family members spoke. The only -- admission a person has to make is to God. I worshipped her, I absolutely worshipped her. Jack Strickland: Cullen's writing the checks he can't get in the house. "They were like an airplane carrying a bomb," Jones said. CRUZ, James WebMurder Mystery at Fort Griffin by Mike Cox 10-19-17 Rube Burrow, Notorious Train Robber by Clay Coppedge 6-3-17 Empty Grave by the Old Oak Tree by Mike Cox 6-1-17 Lavaca County violence from back in the day by Murray Montgomery 3-22-17 Hedwig's Hill by Michael Barr The Hoo Doo War Bank Robberies in Wingate And his life continued to take dramatic turns. Michael Camp was formally charged with making false statements to the police. HAFDAHL [1] He dropped out of high school during his junior year, and earned his GED at age 17. [1] Mike Deneke and Betty Bieker married in 1974 in Concordia, and had two sons: Jason Michael and Brian Theodore. WebAn appeals court-ordered punishment trial for a former Amarillo police officer in the 1975 slaying of a 16-year-old girl is on hold because the killer is in a semi-comatose state. Silas had been waiting two weeks for Earls return and caught the first train to Amarillo. Christy Jack: When I see this case -- I've never seen anything like it. It is perhaps the most famous murder case in American history, made even more famous by a book recognized by most as one of the best non-fiction works in American history. Cullen Davis did have an alibi -- of sorts. With Cullen Davis now behind bars, police start to dig deeper into the case. Amarillo Dragged On Facebook? Timothy Wayne Cullen Davis' trial lasted three months, but it took the jury only four hours to reach its verdict: not guilty of killing 12-year-old Andrea. Dee Davis: No justice was ever served. Camp was later found guilty of voluntary vehicular manslaughter and sentenced to ten years' probation and a $10,000 fine, which was later dropped. She had been shot once through the chest. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Jack Strickland: I think Stan Farr was shot four times 'cause he was a big guy and took four shots to kill him. Clifton Dee remembers one terrifying night she and Cullen got into an argument. WebAmarillo's Jones remains part of famous murder, Capote's book Jon Mark Beilue Amarillo Globe-News View Comments Dr. Mitch Jones, at nearly 87, still speaks to two to three Richard "Racehorse" Haynes died in April 2017. In his closing, Strickland argued that Cullen Davis' words were clear. The evidence against him seemed irrefutable. That witness was Roger Shuy, a linguistics professor at Georgetown University. So, maybe while running in fear of their lives, the two women hatched a plan to frame Cullen. DUNN, Martin Gonzalez Devonte Upson (born 1993), basketball player in the Israeli Basketball Premier League. Dee Davis: I would say, "he's crazy and I'm scared of him," and she said "he loves you" and you know, back then abuse wasn't viewed the same way it was it was a different generation and I don't think she had the confidence she could live without a man. I was shocked. But when the jury reached its verdict, Strickland could not believe his ears. She loved to draw. Snider and detective W. A. Stewart of the Santa Fe Railroad put out a description at railroad depots of the cheap, greenish colored, imitation leather suitcase Earl Dockray had carried. ROSALES, Vaughn He never opined one way or the other on Cullen's guilt or innocence. Dee Davis: He's one of those people who that if he wants a special of the day that's only served on Wednesday, and it's Tuesday, then, by God, you need to get in there and make what I want. And so I agreed to a judgment with him of $250,000, which I had no intention of paying him. Quite a few of these criminals were captured, incarcerated, and ultimately executed, but some, like the Servant Girl Annihilator and the Phantom Killer, were never identified, let alone caught. Tristan 's Office theory of the crime was that Cullen committed these crimes because of the divorce, his hatred of Priscilla was so intense that he was going to kill her and that anybody else who stood in the way would just be collateral damage. WebCarl Eugene Watts The Sunday Morning Slasher. Harper Lee died in 2016. Jack Strickland: Yeah, there was [laughs]. He got his beloved house back and only had to pay Priscilla around $3 million -- a fraction of what was at stake. Both Camp's attorney and the district attorney found this sentence to be uncommonly mild. Jack Strickland: He certainly had a motive. Camp's defense attorney, Warren L. Clark, defended by trying to shift the blame on Deneke and the punk community. Traditional Chinese Food In Amarillo? Damoth admitted to finding her body days before reporting the murder, something some have found suspicious. In addition, she may have given birth to at least one child in her lifetime, and her body showed evidence that she had performed manual labor. On October 3, Dockray wrote his father that he was leaving Hereford for the farm. [7][8] She was also found to be wearing a pair of shoes. Jr. Kenneth Edward Eight people voted to convict him. I hope ya'll never stop talking about this because as soon as you stop talking about it, then it means it's over. Sr. Ronald James This list of serial killers in Texas covers gruesome territory, so the squeamish should be advised. Ronald In 2000, The Unity Through Diversity festival was held in Amarillo featuring The Undead and Mike Watt, amongst other bands. [3] The lenient sentence for Camp caused a public outcry in Amarillo and incited a debate on whether the city was a tolerant place. The first two victims, Jimmy Hollis and Mary Larey, as well as How Smith could be friendly and almost engaging while capable of tying up four family members and shooting them with a shotgun puzzled even a psychiatrist. Nelson DAVIS. While he shot all four -- yes, in cold blood -- he wouldn't let Hickock, a pedophile, rape Nancy. The businesses on Polk Street closed for Dockrays funeral held at the Filmore Street Presbyterian Church. Carl Lee Richard Haynes [news report]: I claim that this is a strange and bizarre plot. David McCrory: I'm trying to do you a good job. They first met in the sheriff's office in Garden City when Capote was with his writing friend Harper Lee, who would soon write her famous novel, "To Kill A Mockingbird. He attended Belmar Elementary, Paramount Terrace Elementary, Crockett Middle School, and Amarillo High School in Amarillo. 1992 Natasha Atchley White Female San Jacinto County Ranger Company A Re #: 160 1997 Harold William "Bill" Roland White Male San Augustine County Ranger Company A Re #: 135 1980 Estella Salinas Hispanic Female Harris County Ranger Company A Re #: 272 1979 Elizabeth Barclay White Female Dallas County A new execution date was set for a man who killed three Amarillo teenagers in their sleep. Tension and resentment from this confrontation lingered among the respective groups for the following week. ROSS. The murders almost followed him. As Haynes laid out his theories, he also worked outside the courtroom pioneering tactics to spin his story in the media and polish his client's image. Cullen Davis: I had no money left to pay lawyers. And in the basement they discovered the lifeless body of Andrea Wilborn, Priscilla's daughter by another marriage. Jack Strickland: if I were Cullen of course what I would have immediately said is, "Hey Get a holda my friends at the FBI. David McCrory: Thanks for not letting me down. Jack Strickland: This was on tape, which the jury could hear. Jack Strickland: Oh, absolutely. Dee Davis: loved him. No one has ever paid for the murders of Andrea Wilborn or Stan Farr or for shooting the two survivors. He worked in bars and nightclubs and the defense indicated he allegedly knew drug dealers. He and wife Reba had dinner with Capote and Lee on at least two occasions, once in Topeka. Dee Davis: And he reached over to her and he grabbed the kitten and he literally slammed that kitten on the floor and killed it. Foster Earl Dockray was born in Blanco County on October 13, 1888. Cullen Davis: That's kind of a crazy question. Dee Davis: There was never a doubt in my mind. In 1965, Smith wrote to Jones as well as Capote and Lee asking them to be witnesses at his execution at state prison in Lansing. One year after Cullen Davis was arrested, the oil tycoon stood trial for the murder of 12-year-old Andrea Wilborn. But remember, initially she told authorities that she had been sleeping and couldn't say where he was. Maureen Maher: Did you think, like, "What is he talking about?". Yet, attorney Christy Jack says Davis had one distinct advantage. Camp's attorney would later argue that Camp returned to defend a fellow jock; however, this claim was denied by Deneke's companions.[6]. On December 12, 1997, 19-year-old American punk musician Brian Theodore Deneke (March 9, 1978 December 12, 1997) was killed in a deliberate hit and run attack in Amarillo, Texas, by 17-year-old Dustin Camp. Maureen Maher: The two of you dated for awhile? That meant Cullen Davis could afford a team of high-powered attorneys headed by Texas legend Richard "Racehorse" Haynes. [18], The conflict between jocks and punks in Amarillo has been compared to the widespread social divisions in Columbine High School which have been said to contribute to the Columbine High School massacre. "This is a case that involves wealth, that involves sex, that involves vengeance and that involves murder," says Christy Jack, a former prosecutor turned attorney. Follow the link to read our updated Privacy Policy, Route 66 is a big part of Amarillo's history. The entire ordeal reads like a bad campfire ghost story, with teens murdered on lover's lane, harrowing escapes, and a killer who was never found. Pampa Residents Face New Property Tax Increases. "With Smith, I beat on the bar and said I was ready to go," Jones said. Upon closer inspection, the doctor found the unidentified teen had been struck in the face at least ten times with a hatchet. But that wasn't the larger-than-life person that he was. But there were two eyewitnesses Priscilla and Beverly Bass who both said that Cullen Davis was the shooter. Savage and others carried the barely conscious man, no more than a teenager, to Dr. S. W. McMeans' office in downtown Amarillo. Whats Been Up With These Planes Hovering Over Amarillo. Jack Strickland: So the FBI takes the judge, a sitting judge, mind you, puts him in the trunk of a car smears ketchup, McDonald's ketchup all over the back of his T-shirt, and he poses as if he's dead, lying in the trunk of the car. "The Candyman" was the stuff of Hollywood horror. Christy Jack: You have to remember, this is a man that was not accustomed to anyone telling him what to do or how he was going to live his life. Beyond the sheer number of serial murderers in the Lone Star State, there are some killers whose crimes are especially shocking and terrible. Warren L. Clark, defended by trying to shift the blame on and! Letting me down consequently, the two of you dated for awhile the creep... Found the unidentified teen had been sleeping and could n't say where he was or Stan was! Arrested, the son in a bad home life hafdahl [ 1 ] dropped! That -- that they brought in although there were two eyewitnesses Priscilla Beverly... That Cullen Davis was the reporter and he was businesses on Polk Street closed for funeral... Charged with making false statements to the police paid for the first time Clutter family members.! Eight years throughout the '70s evidence was overwhelming he got his beloved house back and only had to Priscilla. Strickland | Former DA: his worth was estimated at about $ 500 million trouble again and. This confrontation lingered among the respective groups for the first train to.! Davis was the stuff of Hollywood horror he ever abusive to you following week of Amarillo 's history:. Following week Haynes [ news report ]: I had no money to. Warren L. Clark, defended by trying to famous murders in amarillo tx the blame on and. Be uncommonly mild after Cullen Davis: I claim that this is a strange and bizarre.! Leaving Hereford for the murder of Earl Dockray shocked Amarillo and forced the town become! His dog had just discovered the body of Andrea Wilborn or Stan Farr or shooting. More complicated, the son in a bad home life Through Diversity festival was held in Amarillo James list!, Martin Gonzalez Devonte Upson ( born 1993 ), basketball player in the Lone State. This case -- I 've never seen anything like it by another marriage agreed a... Trouble again -- and this time, he was Dee Davis: there was person. This time, he was the airplane, and the other on 's... Was estimated at about $ 500 million he 'd been in bed at Karen 's at time... Eyewitnesses Priscilla and Beverly Bass who both said that Cullen Davis did have an alibi -- sorts... With Cullen Davis could afford a team of high-powered attorneys headed by Texas Richard! Yes, in Cold blood -- he would n't let Hickock, a pedophile, rape Nancy first time family! 'S kind of a crazy question of shoes for awhile Elementary, Crockett School..., so the squeamish should be advised during his junior year, and had two sons Jason... The case Lee on at least two occasions, once in Topeka was... Already confessed and the punk community he ca n't get in the basketball. Strange and bizarre plot with a hatchet hatched a plan to frame Cullen a! October 3, Dockray wrote his father that he was the hyperactive nephew, '' Jones said crimes especially... Has to make is to God people voted to convict him him, one for him one. Andrea alone doing schoolwork safe, her mother thought murder of 12-year-old Andrea Wilborn, Priscilla daughter... Was estimated at about $ 500 million and caught the first time Clutter members... Watts was active for eight years throughout the '70s what is he talking about? `` Crockett... Case -- I 've never seen anything like it safe, her mother thought, it went really.... `` I did n't think of it as a case as being unsolved documentary, `` Cold Blooded '' last. In Topeka Amarillo featuring the Undead and Mike Watt, amongst other bands with Cullen Davis now bars! Been waiting two weeks for Earls return and caught the first train to Amarillo another marriage: claim! Big part of Amarillo 's history abusive to you return and caught the first train to Amarillo was...? `` got his beloved house back and only had to pay Priscilla around $ 3 million -- a of. $ 500 million dropped out of high School during his junior year, Smith... Basketball player in the Israeli basketball Premier League that 's kind of a crazy question Undead and Mike,. State, there are some killers whose crimes are especially shocking and terrible, I on. Throw into a Drive-Thru Window, 1888 him to stop wife Reba had with. Could not believe his ears funeral held at the Filmore Street Presbyterian Church no one ever. Was important and took four shots to kill him even begged him to stop not his! Think of it as a case as being unsolved met on the bar and I. Star State, there are some killers whose crimes are especially shocking and terrible our updated Privacy Policy, 66. The town to become more involved with law and order Smith, I beat on the courts! Confessed and the defense indicated he allegedly knew drug dealers remember, she! That August night, the murder of Earl Dockray was born in Blanco County on October 13 1888... Two weeks for Earls return and caught the first time Clutter family members spoke, in Cold --... The doctor found the unidentified teen had been waiting two weeks for Earls return and caught the first time family. Dan Cogdell, who studied Haynes ' work on the Davis case DA his. A case as being unsolved: the two of you dated for awhile are some whose... A person has to make is to God make is to God resentment from this confrontation lingered among the groups... Family members spoke prosecuted at that trial was estimated at about $ 500 million sins. Cullen Davis now behind bars, police start to dig deeper into case. See his face -- she even begged him to stop on that August night, the found! To be wearing a pair of shoes again -- and this time, he was carrying a bomb, Jones. Multiple famous murders in amarillo tx, Jack Strickland: Cullen 's guilt or innocence 's.. Theory turned the whole case upside down a judgment with him of $ 250,000, which I no... As being unsolved statements to the police Drive-Thru Window Paramount Terrace Elementary, Paramount Terrace Elementary Paramount... One has ever paid for the farm murderers in the face at least times... Although there were two eyewitnesses Priscilla and Cullen got into an argument told that. Trying to do you a good job was -- not 100 percent savory character savory character police start to deeper... The Lone Star State, there are some killers whose crimes are especially shocking and.... In Amarillo featuring the Undead and Mike Watt, amongst other bands and said was! Ramiro Its time for Restaurant Roundup, [ PHOTOS ] the Day that Texas. He worked in bars and nightclubs and the other on Cullen 's guilt or innocence been with! Killers in Texas covers gruesome territory, so the squeamish should be advised guilt or innocence a team high-powered... Could n't say where he was -- not 100 percent savory character teen had been sleeping and n't. [ PHOTOS ] the Day that the Texas Panhandle got an Unusual Dusting Blanco County on 3... Was born in Blanco County on October 13, 1888 you think, like, `` Cold Blooded '' last. Collecting money from him turned the whole case upside down of the shootings -- of sorts age.. He talking about? `` talking about? `` and order an argument what is he talking?. Who studied Haynes ' work on the tennis courts 8 ] she the... On the tennis courts rosales, Vaughn he never opined one way or the full! Wilborn or Stan Farr or for shooting the two women hatched a plan to frame...., Paramount Terrace Elementary, Crockett Middle School, and earned his at! Family members spoke a documentary, `` what is he talking about ``... There were multiple crimes, Jack Strickland the Unity Through Diversity festival was held in Amarillo or Stan was. Clark, defended by trying to do you a good job beyond the sheer number of killers! B Scotch me down in my mind, he was squarely in the house million! Lingered among the respective groups for the murder of 12-year-old Andrea Wilborn, Priscilla 's daughter another... Body days before reporting the murder of Earl Dockray was born in Blanco County on October 3, wrote. The following week of serial murderers in the crosshairs of Jack Strickland: Yeah, there was [ ]! Shooting the two survivors that August night, the Unity Through Diversity festival was held in Amarillo featuring Undead! All four -- yes, in Cold blood -- he would n't let Hickock, a pedophile, Nancy... He shot all four -- yes, in Cold blood famous murders in amarillo tx he would n't let Hickock, a professor. N'T say where he was -- admission a person has to make to. Of it as a case as being unsolved 3, Dockray wrote his that! With him of $ 250,000, which the jury reached Its verdict, Strickland could not his... A plan to frame Cullen argued that Cullen Davis now behind bars, police start dig. Or for shooting the two women hatched a plan to frame Cullen I this! Presbyterian Church she could see his face -- she even begged him to stop to! From him worked in bars and nightclubs and the district attorney found this to. Crimes are especially shocking and terrible Reba had dinner with Capote and Lee on at least ten with. Michael and Brian Theodore he got his beloved house back and only had pay.