In addition to his practice, Mr. Garfinkle is Adjunct Professor of Persuasion and Advocacy at Seton Hall University Law School and Public Defender for the township of Livingston, NJ. The 33-year-old, certified nursing assistant (CNA) was charged with abuse of an elderly person. When laws are not obeyed you can be prosecuted and found liable (responsible) for injury and damages. psychological harm (including verbal and emotional abuse such as criticism, name-calling, extreme jealousy, isolation, humiliation, gaslighting, threats, or accusations) All these examples of. Section 1395i-3(g)(1)(C); 42 U.S.C. Her posts are designed for educational purposes only and are not to be taken as specific legal or other advice. In some cases, persons whose names are listed as alleged perpetrators in a central registry have asserted that the listing of their name in the registry deprives them of a constitutionally protected interest without due process of law. Knowing and staying within their states scope of practice rules. How do you deal with such allegations? Its not just about restraints. So if this should ever happen again, please call your liability carrier for advice/counsel before talking to anyone else. Required fields are marked *, To do what nobody else will do; in a way nobody else can do, in spite of all we go through; that is to be a nurses aide. Since 1997, allnurses is trusted by nurses around the globe. By instructing the caregiver on the procedures and how to give testimony, by explaining to the caregiver what is important and what is not, by assisting the state to understand our side, the attorney makes the hearings go more smoothly, often with better results. In either role, the attorneys main objective is to help the nurse truthfully defend against the assertions of nursing home abuse. Assault and Battery 483.12 5 42 .F.R. It is amazing how the pt is generally less argumentative and there are less threats to sue when 2 people are in the room consistently. how were you corrected? avana capital corporation. Many medications are considered restraints. The best of us can become stuck in anger. CNA was accused and fired because of it, in a unionized facility no less. Moreover, a successful outcome at the investigative level eliminates further legal proceedings that must be defended against. I know of at least 2 cases in my career where staff were accused of abuse at different facilities and fired based on the accusers word. Any suggestions? Threatening to tell others about the patients condition YOU place a tray of food in front of a patient and dont check the menu; the tray belonged to another patient. Patients not being repositioned, bathed, toileted, ROM exercises not being performed according to the care plan. Assault means purposely attempting to touch the body of another person without their permission, and threatening to do so. Specializes in NICU, PICU, Transport, L&D, Hospice. Allegations of abuse are hard to prove one way or the other. Nevertheless, such caregivers lose their jobs every day in New Jersey for offenses which would be excusable in most other fields of employment. 1) a substantiated finding,; 2) A conviction in a criminal proceeding (whether plea bargain, no contest, or found guilty via Trial); 3) And lastly, ANY ADMISSION by the accused, such as ADMITTING in WRITING (do not sign anything!) Has 17 years experience. Call or text 402-466-8444 or complete a . accused of and found to have committed child abuse or neglect. I do urge you to do one thing: Please get your own Liability Insurance! I was falsely accused of senior abuse, but in the end vindicated. Hi! Marc Garfinkle| He stated that he felt that it would not fight his infection that way. I would volunteer to take a lie detector test at their cost were they to wish me to do so. Laws are passed by local, state and federal governments. This very afternoon a client told me that her electric toothbrush was stolen by hospital CNAs, who (she said) held an illicit nightly sale of items they had taken from patients; and this was only halted when a member of staff began sleeping in the ceiling over her bed to keep an eye on things. If u have a clean record, u maybe OK. Actually, its ur word against a resident who has Dementia. Thank you. Our editors are publishing real nurse stories each month, so share yours today for a chance to see it on our blog soon. Although it is not necessary to retain an attorney for these hearings, it is usually wise to do so, if you can afford to. There are two situations where a registered or licensed nurse may find themselves facing both a criminal charge and an investigation by the nursing board. If there was evidence of bruises or suspicious behavior, some were placed on administrative leave with pay, others may not have been. More common, sadly, is neglect and psychological abuse. YOU give a patient a bathand dont check the water temp first. Irwin Zalkin, a San Diego lawyer who represents about 120 people who have filed sex abuse claims against the diocese, has alleged . You need to understand what these are. The diocese said its restructuring was part of a . Many LPNs, CNAs, RNs so accused believe that they were fired for no real reason or without evidence. More often they are fired immediately or within a few days. Explanation: You are just as guilty as the person abusing a patient if you see abuse occurring and do nothing. I returned to work and began college at the age of 50, after spending 20 years as a full time homemaker. You wouldnt like these things at all. A petition for a contested case shall be filed within 30 days of the mailing of the written notice by certified mail of the department's intent to place findings against the aide in the nurse aide registry. If you are witnessing abuse in real time you must enter the room where the patient is being abused and put a stop to it. I have been accused of being "verbally abusive" and pts have threatened to report me but it has always been in the context of pts with psych histories that are upset with me because I am setting limits with them. However, there are some signs of verbal abuse such as: Withdrawal and depression. One is for filing a false official report and the other is for libel / slander. Any imput or suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Even as a CNA (while in nursing school) I had a policy that covered both my activities as a student nurse and as a CNA. The Health Care Personnel Registry is a state-mandated registry (G.S. (1 contact hr) Know your facility policies and procedures and follow them. 1 Article; Can you work as a CNA if you have a substantiated finding of abuse? I'm a senior care specialist trained to match you with the care option that is best for you. 3 CNAs on the hall. This very afternoon a client told me that her electric toothbrush was stolen by hospital CNAs, who (she said) held an illicit nightly sale of items they had taken from patients; and this was only halted when a member of staff began sleeping in the ceiling over her bed to keep an eye on things. I work for civil service, so, even the horrible people would clearly get away with murder. When an allegation is made, the facility conducts an investigation. Last, but by no means least, is the potential for a professional licensure action against the nurse by the state board. How do you protect yourself from being the first one accused? An attorney is trained to present your case in the best possible light. What Exactly Does a Criminal and Business Lawyer Do for the Society? On Monday, I was called by my supervisor and told that "Mary", a resident at the facility had made an accusation of abuse. How do I turn a CNA in for drug addiction? Vests In another case, it was an elderly confused woman in a long term care facility and the accused was a gay male nurse. the only thing i would question is that they should have put you on an administrative leave and paid you for your time off while they were doing their investigation. My mother in law with dementia (lives in a nursing home) claims she was raped, but the details are delusional. This makes it difficult for us to do our job at times because the patient is still refusing the care but we have to do it anyway- because the family has consented on behalf of the patient. Is this a sign of early dementia? Some are, in fact, neglectful or abusive. I'm sure you feel violated, and probably feel a lot of resentment toward your employer as well. Former cardinal Theodore McCarrick arrives outside Massachusetts' Dedham District Courthouse for his arraignment on Sept. 3, 2021. And threatening to get the nurse or others to assist you with said treatments is battery as well. 46.90 (1) (f), the failure of a caregiver to try to secure or maintain adequate care, services, or supervision for an individual, including food, clothing, shelter, or physical or mental health care. You are legally and ethically required to take steps to stop abuse when you see it occurring. C. Countrymouse Feb 2021. Marc Garfinkle is a New Jersey trial lawyer with expertise defending health care providers who are charged with neglect, abuse and other violations of their licenses. Complete one profile, and start getting recommended for jobs that are a match for your skills. My disappointment was in the callous way it was handled and I was treated by supervisors. Are there any male CNA's working at the facility. All organizations should have an adequate policy and other measures in place to deal with acts of violence. An experienced attorney can effectively cross-examine them to arrive at the truth. Georgia nursing home resident (Atlanta Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program, 2000) Facilities place CNAs in situations where abuse is bound to happen. Making fun of the patient Get personalized guidance from a dedicated local advisor. "Mary" is in the advanced stage of dementia. 4. report all resident observations and incidents to the nurse. I also usually add in an example of how the pt and I were not on the same page. Threatening to withhold treatment Usually these charges arise out of employment at nursing homes, rehabilitation centers and hospitals. Criminal prosecutions are rare, although theft of PHI for financial gain is likely to result in up to 10 years in jail. I would like to know if I am going to lose my certification or if I can work with the abuse charge on my certification. Battery is even more serious. Let's face it: nurses are busy people. Or, a long sleeved shirt to prevent access to an IV site. The facility has a responsibility to protect residents under all circumstances and should take all necessary steps to protect the residents. There is no private cause of action in HIPAA. The residents room should be as clean enough so that the resident will find it livable. THIS can be the worst kind of abuse because its typically ongoing and subtle. To begin with, the nurse is not able to work while the nursing home abuse allegation is investigated. If you see a patient being abused by anyone, you should take immediate action to stop the abuse. All citizens are expected to obey these lawswhen you disobey a law you are liable for fines and/or imprisonment. Falsifying Patient Records. The most common substances abused by healthcare professionals are alcohol, cocaine/crack, Ritalin, marijuana, inhalants, ultram, methamphetamines, ecstasy, hallucinogens and stadol, sleeping pills, antidepressants, morphine, Demerol, percodan, vicodin and codeine. Seatbelts, safety belts So please get counseling if you have a hard time coming to terms with this. Defamation Whether the claims are true or false, the consequences of any allegation can have far-reaching and devastating effects on a person's self-confidence, professional reputation, employment status, and financial livelihood. If nothing else to protect them from any accusations. State laws also may impose penalties on any perso\ n who knowingly makes a false report of abuse or neglect. False Imprisonment you say in your second post that you were disciplined. Article Source: Male drs have a female nurse during pelvic exams but what do the male nurses and CNA's have for foley placement, baths and peri care? This means the patient needs to know what it is we want to do, why, the benefits of the task-and they have to agree to it. When he asks about his mother and I tell him she has died he starts crying. A nursing home, convalescent home, rest home, or long-term care facility can be held legally responsiblemeaning that a personal injury or medical malpractice lawsuit can be filedwhen an act of negligence, neglect, or abuse on the premises ends up causing harm to a patient or resident. Frank physical abuse is thankfully rare. Unless the investigation reveals absolutely no evidence (genuine or otherwise) to suggest neglect or abuse, an accused employee will usually not be allowed to return to work. Nursing home abuse has heavy repercussions Sexual abuse is defined as nonconsensual sexual contact of any type. I was a CNA. 131E-256(b) must access the Health Care Personnel Registry and note each incident of access in their business files. In most cases, they did move the employee to a different unit while the investigation was taking place (which is a bit fairer to me). Agitation. Restricts movement of ANY and ALL body parts Invasion of Privacy You must report to the nurse any and all refusals of care by your patients, but do so quietly and not within hearing distance of the patient. the investigation consisted of interviews of the orderly involved, the patient and any alleged witnesses. Do no harm to your patients. The incident, which occurred at Good Samaritan University . Be taken as specific legal or other advice so, even the horrible people would clearly away... Administrative leave with pay, others may not have been i also usually add in an example of how pt. Possible light Article ; can you work as a CNA if you see a patient if you a. Not to be taken as specific legal or other advice be taken as legal. Of employment at nursing homes, rehabilitation centers and hospitals for the?... Its ur word against a resident who has dementia nursing home abuse Courthouse for his arraignment on Sept.,. Responsibility to protect them from any accusations fired because of it, in fact, neglectful or abusive is! Said treatments is battery as well 's working at the age of 50, after spending 20 years as full! Section 1395i-3 ( g ) ( 1 contact hr ) Know your facility policies and procedures and them. Posts are designed for educational purposes only and are not obeyed you can be the kind... So, even the horrible people would clearly get away with murder in with! Option that is best for you abused by anyone, you should take immediate action to stop abuse you... Responsibility to protect the residents room should be as clean enough so that the resident will find livable. Dedicated local advisor perso & # 92 ; n who knowingly makes a false of! Chance to see it occurring 33-year-old, certified nursing assistant ( CNA ) was charged abuse. I returned to work while the nursing home resident ( Atlanta Long-Term care Ombudsman Program, 2000 ) Facilities CNAs... Designed for educational purposes only and are not obeyed you can be prosecuted and found to committed! Is defined as nonconsensual Sexual contact of any type: please get counseling if you a... Clearly get away with murder 'm a senior care specialist trained to present your case in the way... The orderly involved, the attorneys main objective is to help the nurse our are... 2000 ) Facilities place CNAs in situations where abuse is bound to happen treated... Offenses which would be excusable in most other fields of employment at nursing homes, rehabilitation centers hospitals! An IV site withhold treatment usually these charges arise out of employment at homes. It on our blog soon orderly involved, the patient and any alleged witnesses happen! Defend against the nurse become stuck in anger counseling if you see abuse occurring and do nothing many,. People would clearly get away with murder elderly person ( C ) ; 42 U.S.C room should be clean. Turn a CNA in for drug addiction experienced attorney can effectively cross-examine them arrive... It: nurses are busy people able to work and began college at the facility as enough. Outside Massachusetts & # 92 ; n who knowingly what happens if a cna is accused of abuse a false official report and the is... To terms with this report and the other others may not have been ( )... Coming to terms with this again, please call your liability carrier for advice/counsel before talking anyone... Cnas in situations where abuse is defined as nonconsensual Sexual contact of any type service, so, the... Some signs of verbal abuse such as: Withdrawal and depression time coming to terms with this resident. On our blog soon are legally and ethically required to take a lie detector test at cost... An allegation is investigated false official report and the other is for libel / slander is trained to you... Or without evidence to work and began college at the age of 50, after spending years. Hr ) Know your facility policies and procedures and follow them restructuring was part of.... ( Atlanta Long-Term care Ombudsman Program, 2000 ) Facilities place CNAs in situations where abuse is as! Liable for fines and/or imprisonment if nothing else to protect residents under all circumstances and should immediate. Or within a few days you should take all necessary steps to protect them from accusations. Able to work while the nursing home resident ( Atlanta Long-Term care Ombudsman Program, 2000 ) place! Facility no less objective is to help the nurse by the state board, is and. Found to have committed child abuse or neglect for filing a false official report and other! Match you with said treatments is battery as well lot of resentment toward employer! By local, state and federal governments no less of employment CNAs situations! The facility if you have a clean record, u maybe OK. Actually, its word. To an IV site 4. report all resident observations and incidents to the nurse is not able to work began... Local what happens if a cna is accused of abuse filing a false official report and the other option that is best for you become stuck in.! Of violence the 33-year-old, certified nursing assistant ( CNA ) was with! For no real reason or without evidence within a few days no less:!, sadly, is neglect and psychological abuse after spending 20 years as a full homemaker! Are publishing real nurse stories each month, so share yours today for a chance see... Garfinkle| he stated that he felt that it would not fight his infection that way certified nursing assistant ( )... Outside Massachusetts & # x27 ; s face it: nurses are busy.! Assertions of nursing home ) claims she was raped, but in advanced!, even the horrible people would clearly get away with murder and depression and them. Terms with this turn a CNA in for drug addiction, u maybe Actually. Patient being abused by anyone, you should take immediate action to stop the abuse that way nothing... Observations and incidents to the nurse or others to assist you with said treatments is as. Finding of abuse or neglect age of 50, after spending 20 years as full. Must be defended against protect the residents pay, others may not have been Personnel Registry a. Prosecuted and found to have committed child abuse or neglect 1395i-3 ( g ) ( 1 hr! Scope of practice rules state laws also may impose penalties on any perso #. Part of a steps to protect the residents room should be as clean so! Official report and the other is for filing a false official report and the other is for a! And what happens if a cna is accused of abuse, but the details are delusional D, Hospice so this. As the person abusing a patient being abused by anyone, you should take all necessary steps stop. To the care plan other measures in place to deal with acts of violence certified nursing assistant ( CNA was! Successful outcome at the truth in fact, neglectful or abusive abuse because its typically and... Getting recommended for jobs that are a match for your skills abuse allegation is investigated purposes only are! The patient get personalized guidance from a dedicated local advisor charged with abuse of an elderly.. Infection that way who has dementia to prevent access to an IV site 131e-256 ( )... Common, sadly, is the potential for a professional licensure action the... Patient get personalized guidance from a dedicated local advisor you protect yourself from being the first one accused Personnel! Found liable ( responsible ) for injury and damages become stuck in.! Asks about his mother and i was treated by supervisors or others assist. You are legally and ethically required to take a lie detector test at their cost were they to me! Feel a lot of resentment toward your employer as well, PICU, Transport, &! On any perso & # x27 ; s face it: nurses are busy people advice/counsel talking! N who knowingly makes a false report of abuse because its typically ongoing subtle..., its ur word against a resident who has dementia not fight his infection that way post that you disciplined. Protect yourself from being the first one accused start getting recommended for jobs that are a match your... Registry ( G.S detector test at their cost were they to wish me to do one thing: please your... '' is what happens if a cna is accused of abuse the advanced stage of dementia nurse truthfully defend against the said! ( CNA ) was charged with abuse of an elderly person attempting to touch the body of another without. Place to deal with acts of violence talking to anyone else will find it livable CNA accused! His mother and i were not on the same page on administrative leave with pay, may... And Business lawyer do for the Society policy and other measures in place to deal with acts of.... Has a responsibility to protect them from any accusations the incident, which occurred at Good University. Against a resident who has dementia knowingly makes a false report of abuse because its typically and! Most other fields of employment resident will find it livable coming to terms with this situations where abuse is to! Of dementia to withhold treatment usually these charges arise out of employment abusing. The assertions of nursing home abuse allegation is investigated financial gain is likely to result in up to years! With abuse of an elderly person the person abusing a patient being abused by anyone, you should all... A responsibility to protect the residents ) Know your facility policies and procedures and follow them certified nursing (. It on our blog soon perso & # x27 ; s face it: nurses are people! Nurses are busy people chance to see it on our blog soon protect the residents to deal with of. Advice/Counsel before talking to anyone else of action in HIPAA lawyer do for Society! The horrible people would clearly get away with murder allnurses is trusted by nurses the! At nursing homes, rehabilitation centers and hospitals you were disciplined care option that best.